Comparing PowerShell Switch Parameters with Boolean Parameters

If you’ve ever take a look at the help output (or TechNet documentation) for PowerShell cmdlets, you see that they list several pieces of information about each of the various parameters the cmdlet can use:

  • The parameter name
  • Whether it is a required or optional parameter
  • The .NET variable type the parameter expects
  • A description of the behavior the parameter controls

Let’s focus on two particular types of parameters, the Switch (System.Management.Automation.SwitchParameter) and the Boolean (System.Boolean). While I never really thought about it much before reading a discussion on an email list earlier, these two parameter types seem to be two ways of doing the same thing. Let me give you a practical example from the Exchange 2007 Management Shell: the New-ExchangeCertificate cmdlet. Table 1 lists an excerpt of its parameter list from the current TechNet article:

Table 1: Selected parameters of the New-ExchangeCertificate cmdlet

Parameter Description



Use this parameter to specify the type of certificate object to create.

By default, this parameter will create a self-signed certificate in the local computer certificate store.

To create a certificate request for a PKI certificate (PKCS #10) in the local request store, set this parameter to $True.


Use this parameter to specify whether the resulting certificate will have an exportable private key.

By default, all certificate requests and certificates created by this cmdlet will not allow the private key to be exported.

You must understand that if you cannot export the private key, the certificate itself cannot be exported and imported.

Set this parameter to $true to allow private key exporting from the resulting certificate.

On quick examination, both parameters control either/or behavior. So why the two different types? The mailing list discussion I referenced earlier pointed out the difference:

Boolean parameters control properties on the objects manipulated by the cmdlets. Switch parameters control behavior of the cmdlets themselves.

So in our example, a digital certificate has a property as part of the certificate that marks whether the associated private key can be exported in the future. That property goes along with the certificate, independent of the management interface or tool used. For that property, then, PowerShell uses the Boolean type for the -PrivateKeyExportable property.

On the other hand, the –GenerateRequest parameter controls the behavior of the cmdlet. With this property specified, the cmdlet creates a certificate request with all of the specified properties. If this parameter isn’t present, the cmdlet creates a self-signed certificate with all of the specified properties. The resulting object (CSR or certificate) has no corresponding sign of what option was chosen – you could just as easily submit that CSR to another tool on the same machine to create a self-signed certificate.

I hope this helps draw the distinction. Granted, it’s one I hadn’t thought much about before today, but now that I have, it’s nice to know that there’s yet another sign of intelligence and forethought in the PowerShell architecture.

Published by


Husband and father; technology consultant, speaker, author, and blogger; Microsoft Exchange architect and MVP; writer, reader, Xbox player, karate student, and music lover. Seeker of balance, reveler in life, learning how to look for the uplifting.

Add to the legend